EVERYDISC— Music catalogue & album ratingsYOUR MUSICAL SOCIAL NETWORK

Independent review

Gugniwy sings songs by Yegor Letov, and it would be better if he didn't. I decided to scribble a couple of words about Billy Novik's talentless creation anyway. I won't even start my favorite conversations here about what kinds of covers there are. The fact is that it turns out there are cases when a seemingly decent musician takes a legend's songs and performs them in his own style, which is absolutely ill-suited for them. And he does it as unemotionally and artlessly as possible, as if he is being forced. And besides that, he even gives concerts with this program. Not only that, he takes not just a few songs, but as many as 19(!), so that it is infinitely dreary for the listener. A couple of decent arrangements don't save the matter, because they would only suffice for a mediocre tribute. If Billy wanted to pay tribute to his idol, he definitely shouldn't have done it this way. The album sounds like a mockery and shows only disrespect for the originals. It's as if Novik is laughing at Letov's legacy. To be honest, 4 out of 10 is even an inflated rating. Apparently that very couple of decent arrangements slightly corrected the overall horrifying impression. Well, and completely replaying "Russian Field of Experiments" in the style of dreary jazz is the move of the year, all in all. Something out of concentration camp torture. I still don't give it, for example, 2, because the opus practically doesn't cause sharp rejection, it is just boring and meaningless. Novik lately on the whole hasn't distinguished himself by originality and variety, it seemed that the last drop would run out soon, and it looks like he is all used up. Verdict - delete, download "Vershki i Koreshki".

Likes: 0

Discussion

Log in to join the discussion