EVERYDISC— Music catalogue & album ratingsYOUR MUSICAL SOCIAL NETWORK

Independent review

Toto did not release a new album, but assembled one from the archives for the All in 1978-2018 box set. Old is New consists of material that had not appeared on official albums, plus 3 songs from the recent best-of collection 40 trips around the sun. Now put that knowledge aside and imagine we are simply listening to a new record by the band. What we get is one of the best albums in their history. The songs are not arranged chronologically, but sequenced conceptually in an attempt to make a proper album. Although with material this good, that hardly matters. Still, the 4 strongest tracks are intelligently placed across the record: Alone, Spanish sea, Chelsea and Struck by lightning. Of these, 3 had already appeared on Trips. Alongside them are Devil's tower, Fearful heart, In a little while and Oh why. Only two tracks could be called filler, and even one of those is practically a bonus: an electronic collaboration with What so not. The result is that OiN stands alongside the best Toto albums of the 70s and 80s, with hits, lovely melodies and worthwhile choruses. Toto have always been a professional pop-rock band, and all the ingredients the style requires are here. Once again, I am amazed by the bizarre criteria some bands use to leave songs off their albums. This often happens when bands produce themselves. Toto have plenty of albums with not a single song on the level of these eight. All in all, this is an album I would happily buy on physical media for my collection.

Likes: 0

Discussion

Log in to join the discussion